Supreme Court of the State of New York Appellate Division Second Judicial DepartmentSupreme Court of the State of New York Appellate Division Second Judicial Department
Calendars Decisions

How a Case is Decided

Appeals and Proceedings

A party aggrieved by a judgment or order that is appealable as of right (CPLR 5701[a]) may appeal to the Appellate Division by filing two copies of a notice of appeal, to each of which must be annexed an Informational Statement, a copy of the order or judgment appealed from, and a copy of the decision, in the office in which the judgment or order appealed from was entered. The appellant must also serve a copy of the notice of appeal upon the opposing party (CPLR 5515[1]; 22 NYCRR 1250.3[a]). In civil cases originating in the Supreme Court, a filing fee of $65 is payable to the county clerk (CPLR 8022[a]). There are also certain time limits imposed on the filing of a notice of appeal (CPLR 5513).

Proceedings may be commenced in the Appellate Division (CPLR 506; 22 NYCRR 1250.13) either by serving and filing a notice of petition and petition, or by order to show cause and petition, filing an Informational Statement, and paying the $315 filing fee required by CPLR 8022(b) and § 1250.17(a) of the rules of the Appellate Division (22 NYCRR 1250.17[a][1]).

Proceedings pursuant to CPLR article 78 which are transferred to this court pursuant to CPLR 7804(g) must be perfected in the same manner as an appeal (22 NYCRR 1250.12[a]).

Perfecting an Appeal or Proceeding

Once an appeal is taken by filing a notice of appeal or obtaining an order granting leave to appeal, or a proceeding is transferred to or duly commenced in this court, it must be "perfected". An appeal or proceeding is perfected when the appellant or petitioner has taken all the steps necessary to place it on the court's calendar. Generally, this means filing a brief and providing the court with the papers that led to the determination under review. There are three main methods for perfecting an appeal (22 NYCRR 1250.5). The first is the full record method, which requires the party to print all the papers which were before the court which made the judgment or order which is the subject of the appeal in a booklet called the record on appeal and to serve and file it with a brief setting forth their contentions. The second is the appendix method, which is similar to the full record method except that those parts of the papers that are not germane to the appeal need not be printed. The third is the original papers method, in which the appellant or petitioner serves and files a brief, and subpoenas the original papers for filing with the clerk of the Appellate Division, Second Department. The full record and appendix method are predominantly used to perfect civil causes and the original papers method is used predominantly to perfect Family Court and criminal causes (22 NYCRR 1250.5[e]). The requirements concerning the form and the content of records, appendices, and briefs can be found in CPLR 5526, 5528, 5529, and §1250.7 of the rules of the Appellate Division (22 NYCRR 1250.7).

Pursuant to § 1250.9[a] of the rules of the Appellate Division, an appellant has six months from the date of the notice of appeal, or, in the case of a proceeding transferred to the court pursuant to CPLR 7804(g), six months from the date of the order of transfer, to perfect the appeal or proceeding (22 NYCRR 1250.9[a]). Papers are deemed filed in this court as of the time they are actually received in the clerk's office accompanied by proof of service on all necessary parties. Papers received in the clerk's office after the time to perfect the appeal has expired will be rejected as untimely, even if they were timely mailed, and the appeal shall be deemed dismissed (22 NYCRR 1250.10[a]). The appeal cannot thereafter be perfected unless the appellant successfully moves to vacate the dismissal and for an extension of time to perfect the appeal (22 NYCRR 1250.10[c]).

The General Clerk's Office

The record or appendix and brief on an appeal or proceeding to be perfected is initially received in the clerk's office, which is located on the first floor of the courthouse at 45 Monroe Place. Before the papers are accepted for filing, the clerks determine if they have been submitted within the time limits of § 1250.9 of the rules of the Appellate Division (22 NYCRR 1250.9). Additionally, the clerks examine the papers for compliance with various other court rules. Among other things, the proposed papers are examined for proof of service (22 NYCRR 1250.9), and proper certification (22 NYCRR 1250.7[g]), as well as for proper pagination, proper binding, and proper print size and page margins (22 NYCRR 1250.6; 1250.8). Unless it has been waived, the filing fee must also be paid at the time the record or appendix and brief are submitted.

Upon acceptance of the record or appendix and the brief by the clerk's office, the appeal or proceeding is perfected. In addition to hard copy filings, the court requires that a digital copy of all records, appendices and briefs be submitted via a portal on the home page of its website (22 NYCRR 1250.9). That digital copy must be in compliance with the Court's Technical Guidelines.

The Record Room

The clerk's office stamps each copy of the record or appendix and brief indicating the date and time it was received by the court. It then sends all but one of the copies to the court's record room, where they are held for eventual distribution to the panel of Justices assigned to determine the cause.

For information regarding appeals subject to mandatory electronic filing, please see the e-filing section of the Court's website.

The Data Entry Department

The remaining copy of the papers accepted by the clerk's office is given to the data entry department, where the fact of its filing, the date and time thereof, and the date and method of service, is recorded in the court's computer system.

The Calendar Clerk

From data entry, one copy of the papers on the appeal is sent to the office of the calendar clerk where it is held for the filing of the respondent's brief, the appellant's reply brief, if any, and possible amicus curiae briefs. The calendar clerk re-examines the papers to determine that the appeal has been properly perfected, and dockets the request for argument time, which must be noted on the cover of all briefs submitted to the court (22 NYCRR 1250.8[a]). A notation is made on the calendar of those causes in which argument time has been requested, but in which oral argument is either limited or not permitted under the rules (22 NYCRR 670.15).

When all of the briefs have been received, or the time to file them has expired, the calendar clerk's copy of the papers on the cause is sent to the law department.

The Law Department

The chief court attorney heads the law department, assisted by serveral deputies. They review the causes forwarded to them by the calendar clerk for procedural irregularities that may need to be addressed before the cause is heard. They also note the issues raised by the briefs, and assess them in terms of difficulty and complexity.

Following this preliminary review, each cause is assigned, generally in the order of perfection, to one of a staff of court attorneys assigned to the law department. The court attorney prepares a confidential written report for the panel of Justices that is to determine the cause. Each report contains a summary of the facts and an analysis of the issues. The report is circulated to the panel in advance of the date the cause is calendared for submission or argument.

Calendaring: Argument and Submission Calendars

Once the confidential report on a cause is completed, the cause is placed on the court's day calendar. The assignment of causes to specific calendar dates is the responsibility of the chief court attorney in conjunction with the calendar clerks. Causes in which oral argument is permitted and has been requested are heard on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays from September through mid-June. Oral argument is generally held in the courtroom at 45 Monroe Place, in Brooklyn, but several times a year argument is also held in courthouses in Mineola, Central Islip, and White Plains.

The court holds a submission calendar on numerous Wednesdays throughout the year for causes in which argument was not requested or is not permitted (22 NYCRR 670.15), or in which the court has determined not to hear requested argument.

The calendar clerks and the record room put together the formal calendar, sending it to the New York Law Journal for publication, and distributing the records or appendices and the briefs to the panel of assigned Justices. The Court's calendars are also published on its website.

Chambers Work

In advance of the calendar date, each Justice on a day calendar panel receives copies of the records or appendices and the briefs of all of the parties for each cause scheduled for that date, as well as a copy of the confidential report prepared for each case. The briefs are checked against the record for accuracy, and the Justices may take notes to assist them on oral argument. The law clerk for each Justice does additional research as necessary. A Justice may circulate a supplemental report and/or proposed decision from their chambers.

Calendar Day

On those days when the court sits to hear oral argument, the call of the calendar takes place at 10 a.m. As the calendar is called each attorney rises to indicate the amount of argument time requested. The court's rules do not permit rebuttal argument without leave of the court (22 NYCRR 670.15[f]). An attorney who has submitted a brief without a request for argument time will not be permitted to argue. Any party may forego argument and submit the matter, even when argument has been requested on the cover of the brief.

Following oral argument, the panel retires to the court's consultation room, to consider each cause individually. The Justices discuss each case, vote on an appropriate resolution, and their determination is recorded by a deputy clerk. Those cases that are disposed of by unanimous vote in favor of a draft decision are forwarded to the decision department for editing and eventual release.

Decision Department

The decision department consists of a supervisor, a staff of attorney editors, and a number of clerks and typists. The decision department voting clerk receives the papers concerning each cause directly from consultation and records the vote taken at consultation into the court's computer system. If the voting was not completed after the initial consultation, the voting clerk circulates majority, concurring, and dissenting decisions drafted thereafter by members of the bench, and records the votes as they are received.

The supervisor of the decision department assigns each decision on which the voting is complete to an editor, who then prepares it for publication. Among other things, the editors check citations, grammar, and technical style. They also examine the draft decision for consistency with prior decisions of the court and with proposed decisions on causes that are pending but not yet released.

Decision Release and Remittitur

Following internal review, the Presiding Justice approves the release of the final list of the decisions to the public. Those decisions approved for the week are printed in quantity on the court's press. A set of the decisions is given to the data entry department, where the date and the disposition of the cause are entered in the court's system, and another set is made available to the public in the general clerk's office, and posted on the court's website at 1 p.m. each Wednesday. The decisions are distributed to, among others, the New York Law Journal, the Office of Court Administration, and the State Reporter.

After the cause is decided, the original papers, the record on appeal or appendix, and the briefs are remitted to the clerk of the court of original instance, with a certified copy of the decision. Original exhibits are returned to the parties.