Opinion 23-152

Short-Form Opinion

December 14, 2023

Question:     May a judge with relevant personal knowledge provide an affirmation of good moral character on behalf of a first-time applicant for admission to the bar? 

Discussion:   We have previously advised that a judge may provide a character and fitness committee with an affirmation of good moral character on behalf of a first-time applicant for admission to the bar, provided that the recommendation is based on the judge’s personal knowledge of the applicant’s character.[1]  If the judge wishes to use judicial stationery, the words “Personal and Unofficial” must be prominently displayed.

Enclosed:     Opinions 08-127; 04-31; 91-14; 88-166.

---

[1] This is a different circumstance than a disbarred attorney seeking readmission, which is subject to the usual prohibition on serving voluntarily as a character witness (see Opinion 95-75; 22 NYCRR 100.2[C]).