AD4 Seal

Supreme Court of the State of New York
APPELLATE DIVISION
Fourth Judicial Department

Decisions - March 15, 2013

 
Cattaraugus
A., DONALD, PEOPLE v224KA 12-00721(I10-187)
DEXTER, CHAUNCEY K., PEOPLE v145KA 11-02355(I11-038)
PETTIT, MARK v GREEN, RANDY B.80CA 12-01293(76241)
 
Cayuga
ALIBRANDI, MARY BETH, MTR. OF136CA 12-00963(2010-303)
CRANDALL, RONALD v NYS OFFICE OF CHILDREN AND FAMILY S,168TP 12-01555(2012-0106)
DEANGELIS, WILLIAM JOSEPH v MARTENS FARMS, LLC,15CA 12-01473(09-1178)
DEANGELIS, WILLIAM JOSEPH v MARTENS FARMS, LLC,10CA 12-01385(09-1178)
H., JOHN v STATE OF NEW YORK,121CA 12-00081(118925)
PANEK, GEORGE J., PEOPLE v171KA 12-00536(S2010-083)
POLANCO, WILFREDO v EVANS, ANDREA W.292CA 12-01184(2011-0799)
PRACK, ALBERT, MCFADDEN, REGINALD v165TP 12-01700(2012-0187)
PRAVE, III, ANTHONY v NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE INSURA,35CA 12-00807(0000162/11)
 
Chautauqua
SWEGAN, RICHARD B. v SVENSON, ERIC18CA 12-00987(K1-2009-1621)
 
Erie
ABBOTT, JENNIFER L. v TONAWANDA COKE CORPORATION,155CA 12-01384(2001-2327)
AMERICAN TOWER ASSET SUB, LLC, v BUFFALO-LAKE ERIE WIRELESS SYSTEMS,186CA 12-01779(2008-10067)
B., JR., CHRISTOPHER, MTR. OF153CAF 11-02352(B-09470-10)
BROOKS, III, LLORD BYRON v AXA ADVISORS, LLC,138CA 12-01116(1510/2011)
BROOKS, III, LLORD BYRON v AXA ADVISORS, LLC,137CA 12-01114(1510/2011)
COOKHORNE, PAUL v FISCHER, BRIAN162TP 12-01634(2012-1791)
COUNTY OF ERIE, v M/A-COM, INC.,1190CA 12-00076(I2009-12326)
COUNTY OF ERIE, v M/A-COM, INC.,1184CA 12-00075(I2009-12326)
D'ANNA, ANTHONY v KENMORE-TOWN OF TONAWANDA UNION FRE,763CA 11-01463(I2009-03035)
DARK, DAVAN, PEOPLE v92KA 11-00966(I2010-0788)
DAVIS, DANICA v BOND, JUSTIN K.281CAF 12-00553(F-07855-09/11D)
EVERETT, REBECCA J., MTR. OF51CA 12-01283(2006-0362/A)
FAUNTLEROY, KAREEM v FISCHER, BRIAN317TP 12-01582(I-2012-01282)
GARVEY, MARIE M. v MEDAMERICA FINGERLAKES LONG TERM,39CA 12-01461(I2008/13133)
GASTON, VICTOR, PEOPLE v176KA 11-00406(I2009-2299)
GEORGETOWN CAPITAL GROUP, INC., v EVERST NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY,82CA 12-01337(I2011-604861)
G., LILLIANNA, MTR. OF262CAF 12-00247(B-4689-11)
GRISANTI, CRISTA A. v KURSS, M.D., DAVID I.213CA 12-01378(2007/7541)
HAYNES, NIESHA v KALEIDA HEALTH,181CA 11-02507(I2009/011310)
HEARY, RICHARD, PEOPLE v180KA 11-01378(I2010-01777)
JACKSON, JR., JESSIE B. v SCHWAB, JAMES A.140CA 12-01393(I2007-3511)
JONES, JESSE, PEOPLE v192KA 11-01186(I2009-01279)
JULIUS, DONALD, PEOPLE v175KA 11-01384(I2008-00976I)
KHANJANI, S. SHANE v SCHREIBER, NORMAN141CA 12-00494(I2007-11175)
LISKIEWICZ, CARRIE v HAMEISTER, MARY E.160CA 12-01320(I2009-011607)
QUINNEY, ALFONZO, PEOPLE v109KA 11-00942(I1934-99)
SCIARA, RENEE v SURGICAL ASSOCIATES OF WESTERN NEW, YORK, P.C.1466CA 12-00809(I2010-4659)
SCIARA, RENEE v SURGICAL ASSOCIATES OF WESTERN NEW, YORK, P.C.1467CA 12-00810(I-2010-4659)
SCULLY, CAROL H. v SCULLY, DANIEL J.31CA 12-00519(SF901218/2010)
STEIGER, GARY v LPCIMINELLI, INC.,1439CA 12-01229(I 2008 - 6746)
THOMAS, DAVID v ZBA OF TOWN OF GRAND ISLAND,242CA 12-01201(2011/1593)
WALLACE, DIONNE v KALEIDA HEALTH,239CA 12-01808(2010-63)
WILKINS, MEL T., PEOPLE v90KA 11-00190(I2007-2570)
WILSON, NJERA A., PEOPLE v1179KA 10-02347(I2009-02506)
 
Herkimer
MARTIN, WILLIAM F. v UNITED PARCEL SERVICE OF AMERICA,135CA 12-01377(85606/2007)
 
Jefferson
THIRTY ONE DEVELOPMENT, LLC, v COHEN, JEFFREY161CA 11-02577(2010-2667)
 
Lewis
HOGAN, MARK v VANDEWATER, DAVID117CA 12-01437(CA2008-000498)
 
Livingston
FINCH, TARHENE v BROWN, DAWSON23KAH 11-00862(1183-2010)
GREEN, JOE W., PEOPLE v254KA 11-00973(I2004-226)
 
Monroe
ALEXANDER, BRANDY, PEOPLE v253KA 06-01240(I2005-0618A)
BABCOCK, JR., WILLIAM J. v SCHOENBERGER, H. ROBERT188CA 12-00456(2008/11772)
BROWN, DONNELL M., PEOPLE v174KA 08-02511(I2007-1003)
BROWNLEE, ERIC, PEOPLE v195KA 11-02524(I2002-0493)
COLEMAN, KERRY A., PEOPLE v25KA 09-01157(S2009-3090-A)
COOKE, JAMAL, PEOPLE v146KA 11-01849(I2011-3031)
CUBI, MANUEL, PEOPLE v279KA 09-02650(I2008-0633)
DUKES, JESSIE J., PEOPLE v325KA 11-02115(I2004-0256)
HOELTKE, JOANN v ALLCARE DENTAL AND DENTURES,236CA 12-00052(17401-09)
KING, GREG, PEOPLE v170KA 12-00162(I2001-0151)
LOMAGLIO, LARRY J. v LOMAGLIO, CARMEN M.142CA 12-01317(653-97)
LUDWIG, DANIEL A., PEOPLE v110KA 11-01915(I2010-0932)
MCFADDEN, STEPHEN, PEOPLE v249KA 09-00530(I2008-0434)
MILLER, JOSHUA, PEOPLE v257KA 08-02486(I2008-0232)
NARY, II, WALTER J. v JONIENTZ, ROSEMARY36CA 12-01503(2010-485)
PORTER, KEVIN, PEOPLE v250KA 11-02402(I2008-0874)
SICILIANO, STANLEY v PARRINELLO, ESQ., JOHN R.316CA 12-00981(07/16463)
SICILIANO, STANLEY v PARRINELLO, ESQ., JOHN R.315CA 12-00980(07/16463)
SULLIVAN, THOMAS M. v TROSER MANAGEMENT, INC.,14CA 12-01422(3022/03)
ZEMBIEC, THOMAS C. v COUNTY OF MONROE,1320CA 11-02261(10/09535)
 
Niagara
ALLEN, ANTHONY J., PEOPLE v129KA 11-00328(I2009-283)
GILLOTTI, NEIL, PEOPLE v89KA 12-00297(MILITARY TRANSFER)
GOUPIL, MARK, PEOPLE v200KA 12-01787(2009-204)
SANDY, KEVIN D., PEOPLE v199KA 11-01949(I2011-089)
SPINA, DESTINY v KIMPEX, INC.,1115CA 12-00772(135445)
 
Onondaga
CHINN, SAM, PEOPLE v127KA 98-05247(96-0080-1)
FONSECA, MIGUEL A. v CRONK, DENISE A.85CA 12-01321(10-1173)
FUDGE, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v128KA 10-00386(I2008-0998-1)
G., GABRIELLA, MTR. OF28CAF 12-00078(NN-4140-4141-11)
HAYWARD BAKER, INC., v C.O. FALTER CONSTRUCTION CORP.,1442CA 12-00540(2007-8581)
HAYWARD BAKER, INC., v C.O. FALTER CONSTRUCTION CORP.,1441CA 12-00398(2007-8581)
KIRK, CHRISTY A. v UNIVERSITY OB-GYN ASSOCIATES, INC.,159CA 12-01405(2009-4893)
LEE, SHALITTA T. v WILLIAMS, ANTHONY MONTEZ331CAF 12-00774(F-01884-09/11B)
LIFSON, ALEXANDER v CITY OF SYRACUSE,185CA 12-01805(01-0877)
M., DAHMANI, MTR. OF1429CAF 11-02140(B-1363-11)
MENDEZ, FELIX, PEOPLE v47KA 09-01194(I2009-0016-1)
PIEPER, STEVEN, PEOPLE v273KA 12-00156(I2011-0188-1)
SCOTT, HENRY T. v GRAHAM, HAROLD280KAH 11-01017(2011-0990) & (INDEX)
VOSS, DEBORAH v THE NETHERLANDS INSURANCE COMPANY,284CA 11-02143(CA2008-001771)
VOSS, DEBORAH v THE NETHERLANDS INSURANCE COMPANY,285CA 11-02144(2009-0441)
 
Ontario
BECKWITH, DOUGLAS B., PEOPLE v194KA 12-00044(I11-07-118)
COLLINS, STEPHEN M., PEOPLE v252KA 12-00041(S02-DI-95)
GAY, TIMOTHY J., PEOPLE v193KA 11-01781(S08-DI-155)
HAYNES, JR., HERBERT H., PEOPLE v46KA 11-00490(I09-10-155)
OSGOOD, JASON B., PEOPLE v196KA 11-01164(I10-04-081)
OSGOOD, JASON B., PEOPLE v197KA 11-02325(I10-04-081)
 
Orleans
CARTER, MICHAEL S., PEOPLE v198KA 11-02544(I10-41)
ORTIZ, KENNETH R., PEOPLE v178KA 11-02532(S11-S-11)
ORTIZ, KENNETH R., PEOPLE v173KA 11-02530(I10-99)
 
Oswego
DUNSMOOR, WILLIAM v TOWN OF OSWEGO PLANNING BOARD,183CA 12-01224(11-1763)
LA BEEF, ROBERT v BAITSELL, STEVEN H.158CA 12-00733(08-1770)
RODMAN, DAVID C., PEOPLE v151KA 11-02375(I10C-213)
VOTRA, JASON R., PEOPLE v108KA 10-01077(I10C-042)
 
Steuben
MILLER, JEFFREY v NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH,169TP 12-01599(102993)
 
Wyoming
CONWAY, BRIAN E. v FISCHER, BRIAN191TP 12-01713(21,168-12)
KNICKERBOCKER, DARYL v FISCHER, BRIAN221TP 12-01565(21205-12)
PATTERSON, SENECA v FISCHER, BRIAN248TP 12-01865(21,223-12)
WILSON, ANTONIO v EVANS, ANDREA W.156TP 12-01404(21174-12)
      
 MOTIONS AND CRAWFORDS