Justices of the Court
Generally, decision-orders are released two weeks after the conclusion of the term, at 3:00 p.m. An appeal or proceeding not decided on the decision date is still pending before the Court -- check future decision-order releases.
| A., ISMAHAN v WILLIAMSVILLE BOARD OF EDUCATION, 930 | CA 20-01445 | (812552/2017) | 930 | CA 20-01445 | (812552/2017) |
| ALLEGHANY CONSTRUCTION INC., v CHAUTAUQUA WOODS CORP., 1006 | CA 21-00601 | (EK1 2019 001328) | 1006 | CA 21-00601 | (EK1 2019 001328) |
| ALLEGHANY CONSTRUCTION INC.,, v CHAUTAUQUA WOODS CORP., 1005 | CA 21-00774 | (EK1 2019 001328) | 1005 | CA 21-00774 | (EK1 2019 001328) |
| ALLINGTON, JEFFREY E. v TEMPLETON FOUNDATION, 1158 | CA 21-00582 | (E2014-0312CV) | 1158 | CA 21-00582 | (E2014-0312CV) |
| ALLINGTON, JEFFREY E. v TEMPLETON FOUNDATION, 1157 | CA 21-00412 | (E2014-0312CV) | 1157 | CA 21-00412 | (E2014-0312CV) |
| APPLETON, ALBERT B., PEOPLE v 1123 | KA 20-01182 | (I2020-0184-2) | 1123 | KA 20-01182 | (I2020-0184-2) |
| ASHBY, KEVIN A., PEOPLE v 1055 | KA 16-00797 | (I2014-510) | 1055 | KA 16-00797 | (I2014-510) |
| B.-C., NICHOLAS, MTR. OF 1152 | CAF 21-00082 | (B-09784/85-18) | 1152 | CAF 21-00082 | (B-09784/85-18) |
| B.-M., CAROLA v NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF TEMPORARY, 968 | TP 19-01463 | (18-44590) | 968 | TP 19-01463 | (18-44590) |
| BATTLE, SHAQUILL, PEOPLE v 1017 | KA 15-01127 | (I2013-1092A) | 1017 | KA 15-01127 | (I2013-1092A) |
| BROWN, RICHARD, PEOPLE v 1059 | KA 19-01453 | (I2018-0780-1 Superceding | 1059 | KA 19-01453 | (I2018-0780-1 Superceding |
| BROWN, TRAMMELL, PEOPLE v 1079 | KA 20-00144 | (I2019-0470-1) | 1079 | KA 20-00144 | (I2019-0470-1) |
| CARTER, TRAVIS, PEOPLE v 1035 | KA 20-00249 | (SI-2019-0180-1) | 1035 | KA 20-00249 | (SI-2019-0180-1) |
| CHANDLER, JOSIAH J., PEOPLE v 1128 | KA 16-00330 | (I2014-550) | 1128 | KA 16-00330 | (I2014-550) |
| CITY OF LOCKPORT, MTR. OF 1140 | CA 21-00340 | (E172387/2020) | 1140 | CA 21-00340 | (E172387/2020) |
| CITY OF UTICA, v MALLETTE, MICHELLE 852 | CA 20-00864 | (ca2013-001876) | 852 | CA 20-00864 | (ca2013-001876) |
| CONNELL, JACLYN v ERIE COUNTY MEDICAL CENTER CORPORAT, 1012 | CA 20-01284 | (814674/2018) | 1012 | CA 20-01284 | (814674/2018) |
| CORTER-LONGWELL, MICHALLA v JULIANO, JR., ROBERT S. 710 | CA 20-01061 | (50305) | 710 | CA 20-01061 | (50305) |
| CORTER-LONGWELL, MICHALLA v JULIANO, JR., ROBERT S. 711 | CA 20-01062 | (50305) | 711 | CA 20-01062 | (50305) |
| CRUMP, SAMANTHA v JOHNSON, NICHOLAS V. 1027 | CA 20-01519 | (810629/2019) | 1027 | CA 20-01519 | (810629/2019) |
| DAVIS, EVAN v TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF VILLENOVA, 889 | CA 21-00092 | (EK12019001825) | 889 | CA 21-00092 | (EK12019001825) |
| DEFIO, JENNIFER, PEOPLE v 962 | KA 15-01321 | (I2014-1007-1) | 962 | KA 15-01321 | (I2014-1007-1) |
| DISTEFANO, FRANCIS L., PEOPLE v 1060 | KA 18-01097 | (I17-04-057) | 1060 | KA 18-01097 | (I17-04-057) |
| DIVITO, STEPHEN T. v FIANDACH, EDWARD L. 683 | CA 20-01338 | (12015013250) | 683 | CA 20-01338 | (12015013250) |
| DOLISON, KEVIN E., PEOPLE v 885 | KA 19-01907 | (I2019-038B) | 885 | KA 19-01907 | (I2019-038B) |
| DOWELL, JOSEPH A. v EST TRISH, LLC, 1135 | CA 20-00588 | (2014EF5170) | 1135 | CA 20-00588 | (2014EF5170) |
| DUBAISHI, JAMALAH S. v TAYLOR, BRINNA K. 1161 | CA 21-00006 | (811791/2017) | 1161 | CA 21-00006 | (811791/2017) |
| DUBOIS, QUINNTON M., PEOPLE v 836 | KA 17-01508 | (I2015-0700) | 836 | KA 17-01508 | (I2015-0700) |
| DURKIN, MARY E. v PETRIE, JOHN 1007 | CA 20-00992 | (E2018-1318CV) | 1007 | CA 20-00992 | (E2018-1318CV) |
| E., BRIANNA, MTR. OF 1086 | CAF 20-00951 | (NA-0245-19, NA-0246-19) | 1086 | CAF 20-00951 | (NA-0245-19, NA-0246-19) |
| EDWARDS, AVERY, PEOPLE v 764 | KA 20-01300 | (I12-0996-1) | 764 | KA 20-01300 | (I12-0996-1) |
| ELIBOL, LISA v STATE OF NEW YORK, 1159 | CA 21-00756 | (M-95595) | 1159 | CA 21-00756 | (M-95595) |
| FIELDS ENTERPRISES INC., v BRISTOL HARBOUR VILLAGE ASSOCIATION, 1013 | CA 20-01190 | (127103-2020) | 1013 | CA 20-01190 | (127103-2020) |
| GAMBLIN, KATHY v NAM, MIMI 850 | CA 21-00405 | (816459/2018) | 850 | CA 21-00405 | (816459/2018) |
| GOODWIN, TERICK R., PEOPLE v 1016 | KA 20-01571 | (I2018-116) | 1016 | KA 20-01571 | (I2018-116) |
| GOW, MARCIA L. v GALENSKI, DENNIS D. 1160 | CA 21-00086 | (E172282/2020) | 1160 | CA 21-00086 | (E172282/2020) |
| GRABOWSKI, JOHN M., PEOPLE v 1033 | KA 19-01046 | (I6124) | 1033 | KA 19-01046 | (I6124) |
| GREER, JR., DWAYNE R., PEOPLE v 1122 | KA 17-01109 | (I2016-0608A) | 1122 | KA 17-01109 | (I2016-0608A) |
| HARGIS, JR., DELBERT W. v PRITTY-PITCHER, VICTORIA ANN 1063 | CAF 21-00214 | (V-2452-12/19I) | 1063 | CAF 21-00214 | (V-2452-12/19I) |
| HARRISON, SID, PEOPLE v 1076 | KA 20-01184 | (I2019-138) | 1076 | KA 20-01184 | (I2019-138) |
| HIDALGO-HERNANDEZ, JONATHAN, PEOPLE v 982 | KA 21-00653 | (2019-0659-1) | 982 | KA 21-00653 | (2019-0659-1) |
| HILTS, THOMAS D. v ROGGIE FARMS, LLC, 975 | CA 20-01555 | (E2019-0546) | 975 | CA 20-01555 | (E2019-0546) |
| IMPELLIZZERI, DAVID v STATE OF NEW YORK, 1155 | CA 21-00710 | (128673) | 1155 | CA 21-00710 | (128673) |
| JAKES-JOHNSON, PHILIP v GOTTLIEB, ESQ., ROBERT C. 976 | CA 21-00287 | (E2020-0729) | 976 | CA 21-00287 | (E2020-0729) |
| JANOWSKY, MICHAEL v MONTE, EMILY 1001 | CAF 20-00198 | (V-03272-15/18B,) | 1001 | CAF 20-00198 | (V-03272-15/18B,) |
| JENNINGS, JERMAINE, PEOPLE v 141 | KA 18-00637 | (I2017-0149-1) | 141 | KA 18-00637 | (I2017-0149-1) |
| JONES MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, v MAIN STREET AMERICA ASSURANCE, 894 | CA 21-00173 | (45657) | 894 | CA 21-00173 | (45657) |
| JONES MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, v MAIN STREET AMERICA ASSURANCE, 895 | CA 21-00251 | (45657) | 895 | CA 21-00251 | (45657) |
| K., NORMAN v POSNER, M.D., ALAN 1091 | CA 20-00267 | (813966/2014) | 1091 | CA 20-00267 | (813966/2014) |
| KALEIDA HEALTH, v HYLAND, MARGARET 920 | CA 21-00752 | (E170893/2019) | 920 | CA 21-00752 | (E170893/2019) |
| KAVANAUGH, JAMES v KAVANAUGH, MARTHA 703 | CA 20-01024 | (801916/2019) | 703 | CA 20-01024 | (801916/2019) |
| KAVANAUGH, MATTHEW v KAVANAUGH, NEIL 704 | CA 20-01025 | (812636/2017) | 704 | CA 20-01025 | (812636/2017) |
| L., SYLVIN N., MTR. OF 1061 | CAF 20-01477 | (NN-16574-19, NN-16573-19 | 1061 | CAF 20-01477 | (NN-16574-19, NN-16573-19 |
| LEWIS, DON, PEOPLE v 1037 | KA 19-01650 | (I02289D-2016) | 1037 | KA 19-01650 | (I02289D-2016) |
| MAGEE, TYLER D., PEOPLE v 862 | KA 19-00969 | (I2014-0791) | 862 | KA 19-00969 | (I2014-0791) |
| MALONEY, ROBERT v DEROBERTS, M.D, DEAN 1045 | CA 21-00431 | ( 006507/2020) | 1045 | CA 21-00431 | ( 006507/2020) |
| MARIO, MARC A. v NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF, HUMAN RIGHTS 754 | TP 20-01596 | (2020-001045) | 754 | TP 20-01596 | (2020-001045) |
| MARSFELDER, KAYLEE v KARLQUIST, JOHN P. 1096 | CA 20-01511 | (84999) | 1096 | CA 20-01511 | (84999) |
| MASHEH, MOHAMMAD M. v JHF MANAGEMENT, LLC, 871 | CA 20-00842 | (2017-EF2767) | 871 | CA 20-00842 | (2017-EF2767) |
| MASSEY-HUGHES, JACQUELINE v MASSEY, SHAWN 985 | CA 21-00255 | (DF2019-00000018) | 985 | CA 21-00255 | (DF2019-00000018) |
| MCAVOY, SPENSER v CITY OF ROCHESTER, 891 | TP 21-00787 | (E2020005158) | 891 | TP 21-00787 | (E2020005158) |
| MCCULLOCH, ELIZABETH v CORNERSTONE COMMUNITY FEDERAL CREDI, 1115 | CA 21-00073 | (8070009/2020) | 1115 | CA 21-00073 | (8070009/2020) |
| MCDERMOTT, MARK K., PEOPLE v 1078 | KA 20-00591 | (II19-133) | 1078 | KA 20-00591 | (II19-133) |
| MINTZ, STEPHANIE v CITY OF ROCHESTER, 916 | CA 21-00579 | (E2020004566) | 916 | CA 21-00579 | (E2020004566) |
| MITCHELL, EDWARD v ANNUCCI, ANTHONY 1162 | CA 21-00069 | (814674/2019) | 1162 | CA 21-00069 | (814674/2019) |
| MOHAWK VALLEY HEALTH SYSTEM, v SMITH, MARK 1107 | CA 20-01239 | (EFCA2019-000810) | 1107 | CA 20-01239 | (EFCA2019-000810) |
| MORROW, CRYSTAL v BRIGHTHOUSE LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, OF NY 872 | CA 21-00046 | (802127/2017) | 872 | CA 21-00046 | (802127/2017) |
| MOSLEY, FAROD, PEOPLE v 924 | KA 18-01882 | (I2016-0678-1) | 924 | KA 18-01882 | (I2016-0678-1) |
| MOSLEY, FAROD, PEOPLE v 929 | KA 18-01883 | (I2016-0357-1) | 929 | KA 18-01883 | (I2016-0357-1) |
| MOSS, DWIGHT, PEOPLE v 925 | KA 17-00230 | (I2016-0479) | 925 | KA 17-00230 | (I2016-0479) |
| MURRAY, CHRISTINA M. v SMINKEY, INGE K. 1010 | CA 21-00281 | ( E2018010094) | 1010 | CA 21-00281 | ( E2018010094) |
| NAROLIS, ASHLEY v LEWIS, JR., LORNE B. 1062 | CAF 20-01144 | (V-01481-16/19G) | 1062 | CAF 20-01144 | (V-01481-16/19G) |
| NATIONWIDE AFFINITY INSURANCE COMPA, v RIDGEWOOD DIAGNOSTIC LABORATORY LLC, 1049 | CA 20-01229 | (10477/2019) | 1049 | CA 20-01229 | (10477/2019) |
| NEWMAN, RYAN J., PEOPLE v 921 | KA 15-01502 | (I2014-0369) | 921 | KA 15-01502 | (I2014-0369) |
| NIEVES-CRUZ, RAFAEL, PEOPLE v 748 | KA 17-01356 | (I17-01-002) | 748 | KA 17-01356 | (I17-01-002) |
| O'SHEA, TIMOTHY B. v FEMIA, M.D., JOSEPH F. 918 | CA 20-01466 | (EFCA2017-000430) | 918 | CA 20-01466 | (EFCA2017-000430) |
| OLIVER, CAMELL, PEOPLE v 1172 | KA 18-02197 | (I2018-0395-1) | 1172 | KA 18-02197 | (I2018-0395-1) |
| OLIVER, CAMELL, PEOPLE v 1173 | KA 21-00045 | (I2018-0499-1) | 1173 | KA 21-00045 | (I2018-0499-1) |
| OTT, ANTHONY N., PEOPLE v 905 | KA 19-01420 | (I2005-0717A) | 905 | KA 19-01420 | (I2005-0717A) |
| OWENS, PHILLIP H. v STATE OF NEW YORK, 873 | CA 20-01569 | (133716) | 873 | CA 20-01569 | (133716) |
| PAGAN, HECTOR, PEOPLE v 1058 | KA 18-00407 | (I16-07-146) | 1058 | KA 18-00407 | (I16-07-146) |
| PARKS, DAVID, PEOPLE v 815 | KA 18-02422 | (I2017-1054-1) | 815 | KA 18-02422 | (I2017-1054-1) |
| PEREZ, LAWRENCE, MTR. OF 1046 | CA 20-01181 | (22,014-19) | 1046 | CA 20-01181 | (22,014-19) |
| PFEIFFER, NOAH R. v KARLQUIST, JOHN P. 1095 | CA 20-01510 | (85062) | 1095 | CA 20-01510 | (85062) |
| PORTER, TONI A., PEOPLE v 816 | KA 16-01771 | (I2015-0579B) | 816 | KA 16-01771 | (I2015-0579B) |
| PRESSLEY, BRIAN J., PEOPLE v 1018 | KA 16-02270 | (I2015-0331) | 1018 | KA 16-02270 | (I2015-0331) |
| PRITTY-PITCHER, VICTORIA A. v HARGIS, JR., DELBERT W. 1064 | CAF 21-00215 | (V-02452-12/20N) | 1064 | CAF 21-00215 | (V-02452-12/20N) |
| RAYMOND, LATOYA D., PEOPLE v 1052 | KA 18-01924 | (I17-027) | 1052 | KA 18-01924 | (I17-027) |
| REVERE, GRETCHEN v BURKE, D.O., ROBERT P. 848 | CA 20-01425 | (EFCA2016-330) | 848 | CA 20-01425 | (EFCA2016-330) |
| RIGDON, KEVIN DYLAN v CLOSE, KELLY L. 480 | CAF 19-02066 | (V-00961-14/19C) | 480 | CAF 19-02066 | (V-00961-14/19C) |
| ROBSHAW & VOEKL, P.C., v STANKIEWICZ, JENNIFER KRYSTYNA 1069 | CA 21-00242 | (815519/2018) | 1069 | CA 21-00242 | (815519/2018) |
| RODRIGUEZ-RICARDO, DANIEL, PEOPLE v 1084 | KA 17-01091 | (I2017-0063) | 1084 | KA 17-01091 | (I2017-0063) |
| ROTH & ROTH, v CITY OF ROCHESTER, 1067 | CA 21-00675 | (E2020007203) | 1067 | CA 21-00675 | (E2020007203) |
| RUBINO, ANTHONY, PEOPLE v 1032 | KA 19-00513 | (I01988-2018 / S 44048) | 1032 | KA 19-00513 | (I01988-2018 / S 44048) |
| S., PSYD., KERRI W. v ZUCKER, HOWARD 636 | CA 20-00854 | (20195117) | 636 | CA 20-00854 | (20195117) |
| SADDLER, MARIO, PEOPLE v 907 | KA 19-00163 | (I2012-00475) | 907 | KA 19-00163 | (I2012-00475) |
| SAPIENZA, JOSEPH v CITY OF BUFFALO, 914 | CA 20-01017 | (801507/2020) | 914 | CA 20-01017 | (801507/2020) |
| SCHUNK, STEVEN L. v TOWN OF YORK, 935 | CA 20-00729 | (000860-2019) | 935 | CA 20-00729 | (000860-2019) |
| SCHUNK, STEVEN L. v TOWN OF YORK, 934 | CA 20-00018 | (000860-2019) | 934 | CA 20-00018 | (000860-2019) |
| SCOTT, EUGENE H., PEOPLE v 1075 | KA 19-01432 | (I2018-126) | 1075 | KA 19-01432 | (I2018-126) |
| SECURITY PLANS, INC., v HARTER SECREST & EMERY, LLP, 898 | CA 21-00085 | (E2019011486) | 898 | CA 21-00085 | (E2019011486) |
| SHAW, SHARAD v CITY OF ROCHESTER, 130 | CA 20-00026 | (204/2010) | 130 | CA 20-00026 | (204/2010) |
| SMITH, RANDY L., PEOPLE v 995 | KA 18-02020 | (I2017-184) | 995 | KA 18-02020 | (I2017-184) |
| ST. ELIZABETH MEDICAL CENTER, v SOULTS, M.D., CLIFFORD B. 1112 | CA 20-01241 | (EFCA2019-001166) | 1112 | CA 20-01241 | (EFCA2019-001166) |
| ST. ELIZABETH MEDICAL CENTER, v SOULTS, M.D., CLIFFORD B. 1113 | CA 20-01245 | (efca2019-001166) | 1113 | CA 20-01245 | (efca2019-001166) |
| STANG, RICHARD N. v ERIE INSURANCE COMPANY, 803 | CA 20-01666 | (801252/2019) | 803 | CA 20-01666 | (801252/2019) |
| STROUD, KYSEAN v ALIX HOMES, LLC, 1154 | CA 20-01293 | (817723/2018) | 1154 | CA 20-01293 | (817723/2018) |
| STROUD, KYSEAN, PEOPLE v 881 | KA 21-00476 | (I02569-2018) | 881 | KA 21-00476 | (I02569-2018) |
| SYRACUSE SECURITIES INC., v HOMESTEAD FUNDING CORP., 1156 | CA 20-01665 | (004046/2019) | 1156 | CA 20-01665 | (004046/2019) |
| THE CINCINNATI INSURANCE COMPANY, v ACADIA INSURANCE COMPANY, 684 | CA 20-01029 | (E171401/2020) | 684 | CA 20-01029 | (E171401/2020) |
| TRUETT, BRETT B. v ONEIDA COUNTY, 1042 | OP 21-00853 | | 1042 | OP 21-00853 | |
| TUCKER, DWAYNE, PEOPLE v 743 | KA 14-02141 | (I2013-1092C) | 743 | KA 14-02141 | (I2013-1092C) |
| U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, v FARRELL, MATTHEW R. 1011 | CA 21-00581 | (812112/2019) | 1011 | CA 21-00581 | (812112/2019) |
| UHTEG, ROBERT v KENDRA, GARY 1003 | CA 21-00424 | (804003/2015) | 1003 | CA 21-00424 | (804003/2015) |
| UNGER, BERNARD A. v GANCI, MICHAEL 846 | CA 20-00627 | (2013-803067) | 846 | CA 20-00627 | (2013-803067) |
| UNGER, BERNARD A. v GANCI, MICHAEL 845 | CA 19-01255 | (2013-803067) | 845 | CA 19-01255 | (2013-803067) |
| V., GRAYSON R., MTR. OF 910 | CAF 20-00966 | (NA-17580-18) | 910 | CAF 20-00966 | (NA-17580-18) |
| V., GRAYSON R., MTR. OF 909 | CAF 20-00618 | (NA-17580-18) | 909 | CAF 20-00618 | (NA-17580-18) |
| VANDAMME, DONNA v CURRAN, PATRICK A. 899 | CA 21-00743 | (118692/2018) | 899 | CA 21-00743 | (118692/2018) |
| W., JR., ANTHONY, MTR. OF 773 | CAF 20-00429 | (NN-4901-19) | 773 | CAF 20-00429 | (NN-4901-19) |
| WARME, SCOTT C. v BANAS, SAMANTHA M. 948 | CA 20-00963 | (E171333/2020) | 948 | CA 20-00963 | (E171333/2020) |
| WEBSTER CITIZENS FOR APPROPRIATE LA, ND USE, INC. v TOWN OF WEBSTER, 853 | CA 20-00771 | (E2019011898) | 853 | CA 20-00771 | (E2019011898) |
| WILLIAMS, RANDY v ANNUCCI, ANTHONY 1031 | TP 21-00955 | (22133-20) | 1031 | TP 21-00955 | (22133-20) |
| WINTERS, KATHLEEN M. v MUSSMACHER, RICHARD C. 1009 | CA 21-00616 | (D2019-051935) | 1009 | CA 21-00616 | (D2019-051935) |
| WINTERS, KATHLEEN M. v MUSSMACHER, RICHARD C. 1008 | CA 21-00389 | (D2019-051935) | 1008 | CA 21-00389 | (D2019-051935) |
| WRIGHT, MARCUS v HEARD, CHRISTINE 1040 | CAF 20-00193 | (V-12487-19) | 1040 | CAF 20-00193 | (V-12487-19) |
| YEOMAS, ANTUAN, PEOPLE v 883 | KA 18-02070 | (I2017-00079) | 883 | KA 18-02070 | (I2017-00079) |
| YOUNT, II, DANIEL P. v YOUNT, SARAH A. 1041 | CAF 21-00511 | (V-0084 l-12/19E) | 1041 | CAF 21-00511 | (V-0084 l-12/19E) |
