March 18, 2010 COURTROOM:_____ TIME:_10:00 am____CT REPORTER:_____CLERK:_____ SUPREME COURT OF STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF MONROE MOTION TERM CALENDAR HON. MATTHEW A. ROSENBAUM ------------------------------------ 1 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 11-24-2009 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- DISMISS COMPLAINT SHENICE BROWN, INFANT(S), BY THE THORNTON & NAUMES LLP 617-720-1333 PARENT(S) AND NATURAL GUARDIAN(S) for plaintiff FRANCES BROWN VOLGENAU & BOSSE 716-856-3200 for defendant WILLIAM SMITH, GEORGE POWELL, SARAH STUVER (3PP) - vs - TREVETT LENWEAVER SALZER 454-2181 for POWELL WILLIAM H. SMITH, AND GEORGE POWELL IN HIS REPRESENTATIVE CAPACITY AS EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF SARAH SHULTZ STUVER, DECEASED FRANCES BROWN (3PD) RJI No. : 2004/04318 Case No.: 2005-2228 OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 02-07-2005 Pre S&G : 02-07-2006 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 11-21-2005 Post S&G : Total S&G: 05-11-2007 Note: DAVID MCMORRIS,ESQ/LIS SHOST ESQ;DIANE BOSSE ESQ/PAULA NEWCOMB ESQ (SMITH);THOMAS TEVETT ESQ (POWELL) ------------------------------------ 2 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 10-19-2009 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- CONSOLIDATION ANGEL BLACK, IN HER REPRESENTATIV O'CONNELL & ABRONOWITZ 518-462-5601 E CAPACITY ONLY, AS PARENT AND for plaintiff NATURAL GUARDIAN ON BEHALF OF PIERRE HUMPHREY, AN INFANT COHEN & LOMBARDO 716-881-3010 for defendant - vs - BEN PENNETTA AND THOMAS PSCHIERER SEE ALSO 2009/09679 RJI No. : 2006/01830 Case No.: 2009-0567 OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 02-11-2008 Pre S&G : 02-10-2009 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 04-02-2009 Post S&G : Trial Set For: 05-24-2010 Total S&G: 05-14-2010 Note: MARK RICHTER, ESQ-P;CHRISTOPHER DUGGAN,ESQ-D(BEN PENNETTA) ------------------------------------ 3 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-03-2010 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- CROSS MOTION-DENYING MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE/DISMISS 3RD PARTY ANGEL BLACK, IN HER REPRESENTATIV O'CONNELL & ABRONOWITZ 518-462-5601 E CAPACITY ONLY, AS PARENT AND for plaintiff NATURAL GUARDIAN ON BEHALF OF PIERRE HUMPHREY, AN INFANT COHEN & LOMBARDO 716-881-3010 for defendant - vs - BEN PENNETTA AND THOMAS PSCHIERER SEE ALSO 2009/09679 RJI No. : 2006/01830 Case No.: 2009-0567 OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 02-11-2008 Pre S&G : 02-10-2009 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 04-02-2009 Post S&G : Trial Set For: 05-24-2010 Total S&G: 05-14-2010 Note: MARK RICHTER, ESQ-P;CHRISTOPHER DUGGAN,ESQ-D(BEN PENNETTA) ------------------------------------ 4 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 03-08-2010 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- EXTEND TIME ANGEL BLACK, IN HER REPRESENTATIV O'CONNELL & ABRONOWITZ 518-462-5601 E CAPACITY ONLY, AS PARENT AND for plaintiff NATURAL GUARDIAN ON BEHALF OF PIERRE HUMPHREY, AN INFANT COHEN & LOMBARDO 716-881-3010 for defendant - vs - BEN PENNETTA AND THOMAS PSCHIERER SEE ALSO 2009/09679 RJI No. : 2006/01830 Case No.: 2009-0567 OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 02-11-2008 Pre S&G : 02-10-2009 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 04-02-2009 Post S&G : Trial Set For: 05-24-2010 Total S&G: 05-14-2010 Note: MARK RICHTER, ESQ-P;CHRISTOPHER DUGGAN,ESQ-D(BEN PENNETTA) ------------------------------------ 5 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 01-25-2010 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- NOTICE OF MOTION ROUTE 390 CHEVROLET LLC DBA EVANS & FOX, LLP 241-5999 IDEAL CHEVROLET for plaintiff MCCONVILLE CONSIDINE COOM 546-2500 for defendant - vs - 1877 ASSOCIATES LLC RJI No. : 2007/00497 Case No.: OTHER RJI Filed: 07-11-2007 Pre S&G : 07-10-2008 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 10-11-2009 Note: PETER WEISHARR, ESQ (D) ------------------------------------ 6 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-25-2010 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- EXTEND TIME CATHY A. POHL FIX SPINDLEMAN BROVITZ 641-8000 for plaintiff CHAIFETZ & CHAIFETZ 212-594-9410 for defendant - vs - PARISI & BELLAVIA 232-8000 for ANGUS INTERNATIONAL BIJAY K. SHROFF, ANGUS INTERNATIO NAL INC, PV HOLDING CORP. AND NIRAJ BANSAL SUGARMAN LAW FIRM LLP 315-362-8917 for NIRAJ BANSAL RJI No. : 2007/05021 Case No.: MOTOR VEHICLE RJI Filed: 07-03-2007 Pre S&G : 03-02-2008 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 06-03-2009 Note: ROY ROTENBERG ESQ.;FRANK MUGGIA ESQ. (SHROFF);ALBERT PARISI ESQ (ANGUS);MATTHEW GUMAER ESQ. (BANSAL); LARRY CHAIFETZ ESQ ------------------------------------ 7 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-17-2010 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- OTHER RELIEFS: SET ASIDE JURY VERDICT GAIL E RYE CELLINO AND BARNES PC 454-2020 for plaintiff WOODS OVIATT GILMAN STURM 987-2800 for defendant - vs - for LIFTLINE INC AND ROCHESTER GENESEE REGIONAL TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY RJI No. : 2008/08276 Case No.: 2009-0630 OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 08-01-2008 Pre S&G : 08-01-2009 NON-JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 04-13-2009 Post S&G : Trial Set For: 02-01-2010 Total S&G: 11-02-2010 Note: CHARLES BURKWIT,ESQ-P;GRETA KOLCON,ESQ-D ------------------------------------ 8 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 10-14-2009 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- MOTION TO COMPEL SHALLON BRYANT AND JEUEL BRYANT LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 for plaintiff BENDER CRAWFORD & BENDER for defendant DENNIS P. HERRON, ESQ. 244-6000 for CO-COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF - vs - THOMAS O'ROURKE RJI No. : 2008/08900 Case No.: 2009-1970 OTHER RJI Filed: 09-24-2008 Pre S&G : 09-24-2009 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 10-07-2009 Post S&G : Trial Set For: 07-11-2010 Total S&G: 12-26-2010 Note: NEIL J. MCKINNON, ESQ. ; JOANNEKE BRENTJIENS, ESQ.;JURY TRL 7/11/10 ------------------------------------ 9 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 10-14-2009 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- MOTION TO STRIKE SHALLON BRYANT AND JEUEL BRYANT LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 for plaintiff BENDER CRAWFORD & BENDER for defendant DENNIS P. HERRON, ESQ. 244-6000 for CO-COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF - vs - THOMAS O'ROURKE RJI No. : 2008/08900 Case No.: 2009-1970 OTHER RJI Filed: 09-24-2008 Pre S&G : 09-24-2009 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 10-07-2009 Post S&G : Trial Set For: 07-11-2010 Total S&G: 12-26-2010 Note: NEIL J. MCKINNON, ESQ. ; JOANNEKE BRENTJIENS, ESQ.;JURY TRL 7/11/10 ------------------------------------ 10 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 10-14-2009 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- MOTION TO PRODUCE SHALLON BRYANT AND JEUEL BRYANT LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 for plaintiff BENDER CRAWFORD & BENDER for defendant DENNIS P. HERRON, ESQ. 244-6000 for CO-COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF - vs - THOMAS O'ROURKE RJI No. : 2008/08900 Case No.: 2009-1970 OTHER RJI Filed: 09-24-2008 Pre S&G : 09-24-2009 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 10-07-2009 Post S&G : Trial Set For: 07-11-2010 Total S&G: 12-26-2010 Note: NEIL J. MCKINNON, ESQ. ; JOANNEKE BRENTJIENS, ESQ.;JURY TRL 7/11/10 ------------------------------------ 11 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 12-07-2009 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- SUMMARY JUDGMENT EMILY CAMHI DAVIDSON FINK COOK & KELL 546-6448 for plaintiff HANCOCK & ESTABROOK LLP 315-471-3151 for defendant - vs - for ERIC W RUCKERT DDS AND ORAL & MAXILLOFICIAL SURGERY ASSOCIATES RJI No. : 2008/11140 Case No.: 2009-2260 DENTAL MALPRACTICE RJI Filed: 09-14-2009 Pre S&G : 09-14-2010 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 11-18-2009 Post S&G : Total S&G: 12-16-2011 Note: PAUL KELLY,ESQ; JOHN MURAD,ESQ ------------------------------------ 12 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 07-15-2009 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- DEFAULT JUDGMENT @ 10:00 AM PEGGY WEST, AS PARENT AND NATURAL LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 GUARDIAN OF TALECHA WEST AND for plaintiff RODNEY WEST, INFANTS UNDER THE AGE OF EIGHTEEN - vs - for BRYAN BUSACCO, THOMAS GERVASI AND ELAINE GERVASI RJI No. : 2008/12972 Case No.: OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 07-15-2009 Pre S&G : 07-15-2010 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 10-16-2011 ------------------------------------ 13 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-22-2010 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- OTHER RELIEF: JUDICIAL SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM BRITTANY STRICKLAND-WASHINGTON, LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 GLADYS WASHINGTON AS PARENT AND for plaintiff NATURAL GUARDIAN OF JUSTIN WASHINGTON AND EBONY WASHINGTON, WARD NORRIS HELLER & REID 454-0700 INFANTS UNDER THE AGE OF for defendant EIGHTEEN - vs - for KARL WEEKES INDIVIDUALLY AND DBA MELKAR ENTERPRISES AND PATRICK CORRIGAN RJI No. : 2008/15858 Case No.: OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 02-22-2010 Pre S&G : 02-22-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 05-25-2012 Note: NEIL MCKINNON, ESQ; THOMAS REIDY, ESQ ------------------------------------ 14 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-22-2010 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- OTHER RELIEF: JUDICIAL SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM LILLIE GAINES AS PARENT AND LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 NATURAL GUARDIAN OF ERIKA ONEAL for plaintiff AN INFANT UNDER THE AGE OF EIGHTEEN WARD NORRIS HELLER & REID 454-0700 for defendant - vs - for GLENN FLOOD, YARDENA SHAPIR AND YONATHAN SHAPIR, CHRISTOPHER LANPHER AND MARIA LANPHER AND KARL WEEKES INDIVIDUALLY AND DBA MELKAR ENTERPRISES RJI No. : 2008/15859 Case No.: OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 02-22-2010 Pre S&G : 02-22-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 05-25-2012 Note: NEIL MCKINNON, ESQ; THOMAS REIDY, ESQ ------------------------------------ 15 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-22-2010 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- OTHER RELIEF: JUDICIAL SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM KENTRELL TRAMMEL AND JOANNETTE LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 TRAMMEL AS PARENT AND NATURAL for plaintiff GUARDIAN OF YASAY HARVEY AN INFANT UNDER THE AGE OF EIGHTEEN WARD NORRIS HELLER & REID 454-0700 for defendant - vs - for PATRICIA LIPPOLD AND KARL WEEKES INDIVIDUALLY AND DBA MELKAR ENTERPRISES RJI No. : 2008/15860 Case No.: OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 02-22-2010 Pre S&G : 02-22-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 05-25-2012 Note: NEIL MCKINNON, ESQ; THOMAS REIDY, ESQ ------------------------------------ 16 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-09-2010 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- MOTION-TEMP PUBLIC ADMIN/GRANTING PLT LEAVE TO AMD SUMMONS & COM WELLS FARGO FINANCIAL CREDIT STEVEN J BAUM ESQ 716-204-2400 SERVICES NEW YORK, INC. for plaintiff - vs - for ARLENE M. SCHUMAKER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS SURVIVING SPOUSE OF HAROLD E. SCHUMAKER, JOHN DOE (SAID NAME BEING FICTITIOUS, IT BEING THE INTENTIO N OF PLAINTIFF TO DESIGNATE ANY AND ALL OCCUPANTS OF PREMISES BEING FORECLOSED HEREIN, AND ANY PARTIES, CORPORATIONS OR ENTITIES IF ANY HAVING OR CLAIMING AN RJI No. : 2009/01093 Case No.: Foreclosure RJI Filed: 03-24-2009 Pre S&G : 03-24-2010 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 06-25-2011 Note: HEATHER JOHNSON,ESQ-P ------------------------------------ 17 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 12-08-2009 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- DISMISS DEF.'S 1ST & 2ND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES/SUMMARY JUDGMENT MARY CRAWFORD INFANT(S) BY THE ATHARI LAW OFFICE 315-733-9820 PARENT(S) AND NATURAL GUARDIAN(S) for plaintiff GWENDOLYN CRAWFORD RUPP BAASE & PFALZGRAF, L 716-854-3400 for defendant - vs - for EDWARD J MILLER AND KERRI L MILLER RJI No. : 2009/01619 Case No.: 2009-2062 OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 03-30-2009 Pre S&G : 03-30-2010 JURY TRIAL N/I Filed: 10-20-2009 Post S&G : Trial Set For: 09-24-2010 Total S&G: 07-01-2011 Note: JURY SEL 9/24/10 ------------------------------------ 18 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 11-10-2009 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- DISMISS COMPLAINT RABAH MORAN DAVID M GIGLIO & ASSOCIAT 315-797-2854 for plaintiff HISCOCK & BARCLAY, ESQS. 325-7570 for defendant - vs - for CANON PROPERTIES; HERMAN P WOSTL; AND DONALD AVOLIO, RJI No. : 2009/06941 Case No.: OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 11-10-2009 Pre S&G : 11-10-2010 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 02-11-2012 ------------------------------------ 19 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 11-17-2009 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- DEFAULT JUDGMENT/ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES CALVIN BENNETT, WALTER BENNETT LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 for plaintiff DENNIS P. HERRON, ESQ. 244-6000 for - vs - INGRID YEARWOOD RJI No. : 2009/09502 Case No.: OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 11-17-2009 Pre S&G : 11-17-2010 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 02-18-2012 ------------------------------------ 20 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-03-2010 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- CONSOLIDATE DONOVAN HUMPHREY ATHARI LAW OFFICE 315-733-9820 for plaintiff CHELUS HERDZIK & SPEYER P 716-852-3600 for defendant - vs - for EDWARD CAMPANY, EDWARD CAMPANY, WALKER FKA MARTIN ENGLISH, THOMAS PSCHIERER SEE ALSO 2006/01830 RJI No. : 2009/09679 Case No.: OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 10-07-2009 Pre S&G : 10-07-2010 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 01-08-2012 ------------------------------------ 21 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 01-21-2010 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- OTSC AT 10:00 AM SYSCO FOOD SERVICES OF SYRACUSE, RELIN, GOLDSTEIN & CRANE 325-6202 LLC, for plaintiff HOGAN & WILLIG PLLC 716-636-7600 for defendant - vs - for THE NIAGARA AT BARTON HILL, INC., EDWARD FINKBEINER, RJI No. : 2009/12670 Case No.: OTHER COMMERCIAL RJI Filed: 01-21-2010 Pre S&G : 01-21-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 04-23-2012 Note: PAUL GOLDSTEIN,ESQ-P;TAMMY RIDDLE,ESQ-D ------------------------------------ 22 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 10-28-2009 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- DISMISS COMPLAINT ANGELO INGRASSIA, ROUTE 390 LECLAIR KORONA GIORDANO 327-4100 CHEVROLET LLC DBA IDEAL for plaintiff CHEVROLET, ROUTE 390 NISSAN LLC AND 1877 RIDGE ROAD LLC MCCONVILLE CONSIDINE COOM 546-2500 for defendant - vs - for 1877 ASSOCIATES LLC, DAVID H TAYLOR, DOUGLAS F TAYLOR ALSO SEE 2007/00497 RJI No. : 2009/13091 Case No.: COMMERCIAL DIV-CONTRACT CASES RJI Filed: 10-28-2009 Pre S&G : 10-28-2010 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 01-29-2012 ------------------------------------ 23 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 01-19-2010 by PLAINTIFF Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- EXTENSION OF TIME JEREMIAH LYON JOY ELLEN MISRENDINO, ESQ 716-854-1002 for plaintiff - vs - for SIGMA PI EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION INC, SIGMA PI INTERNATIONAL FRATERNITY INC, EPSILON OMEGA CHAPTER OF SIGMA PI INC, SIGMA PI ALUMNI ASSOCIATION INC, GARY BARROW JR, MARK S BRISCOE RJI No. : 2009/13358 Case No.: MOTOR VEHICLE RJI Filed: 01-19-2010 Pre S&G : 01-19-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 04-21-2012 Note: JOY ELLE MISRENDINO,ESQ-P ------------------------------------ 24 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-22-2010 by DEFENDANT Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- OTHER RELIEF: JUDICIAL SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM MAISHA JACKSON AS PARENT AND LIPSITZ & PONTERIO LLC 716-849-0701 NATURAL GUARDIAN OF KIAYRA JUNE for plaintiff AN INFANT UNDER THE AGE OF EIGHTEEN WARD NORRIS HELLER & REID 454-0700 for defendant - vs - for HELENA VATTER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF HAROLD VATTER DECEASED, RE/MAX FIRST FKA REMAX REALTY, IZORA HARRIS, DELOIS BARIDEAUX AND KARL WEEKES INDIVIDUALLY AND DBA MELKAR ENTERPRISES RJI No. : 2009/13555 Case No.: OTHER TORTS RJI Filed: 02-22-2010 Pre S&G : 02-22-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 05-25-2012 Note: NEIL MCKINNON, ESQ; THOMAS REIDY, ESQ ------------------------------------ 25 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-11-2010 by PETITIONER Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- NOTICE OF PETITION-NAME CHANGE IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION FERO PILATO & INGERSOLL E 325-4600 OF ALEXIS RAE MAGANS, A MINOR BY for plaintiff LISA ANN MERRICK HER MOTHER AND NATURAL GUARDIAN TO ASSUME THE NAME OF ALEXIS RAE MAGANS-MERRICK - vs - RJI No. : 2010/00675 Case No.: E072-10 OTHER SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS RJI Filed: 02-08-2010 Pre S&G : 02-08-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 05-11-2012 ------------------------------------ 26 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-11-2010 by PETITIONER Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- NOTICE OF PETITION-NAME CHANGE IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION FERO PILATO & INGERSOLL E 325-4600 OF JOHN TYLER MAGANS A MINOR BY for plaintiff LISA ANN MERRICK HIS MOTHER AND NATURAL GUARDIAN TO ASSUME THE NAME TYLER MAGANS-MERRICK - vs - RJI No. : 2010/00676 Case No.: E073-10 OTHER SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS RJI Filed: 02-08-2010 Pre S&G : 02-08-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 05-11-2012 ------------------------------------ 27 ------------------------------------- Motion Filed: 02-11-2010 by PETITIONER Decision Due: 05-17-2010 Seeking: S- NOTICE OF PETITIONER-NAME CHANGE IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION WOODS OVIATT GILMAN STURM 987-2800 OF MALE COLLIER AKA ALEXANDER for plaintiff DAVID JR FOR LEAVE TO ASSUME ANOTHER NAME OF ALEXANDER DAVID JR - vs - RJI No. : 2010/01628 Case No.: E077-10 OTHER SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS RJI Filed: 02-09-2010 Pre S&G : 02-09-2011 NON-TRIAL Total S&G: 05-12-2012